Every sandwich
tells a story
worth savoring.
Artisan deli counter, olive bar, and gourmet pantry — all under one roof on Brooklyn's Montague Street. We source the finest ingredients so you can taste the difference in every bite.
Our Story
A corner of Brooklyn
built on taste
Olive and Garlic began with a simple conviction: that a great deli should be more than a quick lunch stop — it should be a place where quality ingredients, thoughtful preparation, and genuine hospitality come together.
Located on the bustling stretch of Montague Street in Brooklyn Heights, we've built a neighborhood staple that serves both the daily regular and the first-time visitor with the same care. Our deli counter features house-made sandwiches, our olive bar showcases curated selections from Mediterranean groves, and our market shelves carry pantry essentials you won't find anywhere else in the neighborhood.
100%
Fresh Ingredients
Daily
House-Made
Local
Sourced
What We Offer
From our counter
to your table
Deli Counter
Sandwiches crafted to order — from classic pastrami on rye to our signature Mediterranean wraps. Every ingredient chosen, every combination considered.
Olive Bar
A rotating selection of imported and domestic olives — Kalamata, Castelvetrano, Niçoise, and seasonal specialties. Taste before you buy.
Cheese & Charcuterie
Curated selections from small-batch producers. Whether you're building a board for entertaining or grabbing a quick wedge, our experts will guide you.
Café & Catering
Morning coffee, afternoon pastries, and full catering for meetings and events. We bring the same attention to detail whether it's one sandwich or one hundred.
Gourmet Market
Take the deli experience home. Specialty oils, aged vinegars, imported pasta, artisan jams, and pantry staples — all hand-picked by our team.
Seasonal & Local
We work with local farms and seasonal producers so our selections reflect what's best right now — not what's easiest to ship year-round.
The Market
Bring the taste of
Montague Street
home with you
Our market shelves are stocked with the same products our deli counter is known for — plus a wider selection of international and local finds you won't see elsewhere in Brooklyn Heights. From small-batch olive oils to house-made preserves, every item on our shelves has been tasted and approved.
- Imported and domestic olive oils, aged vinegars, and specialty salts
- Artisan breads, crackers, and fresh pastries baked daily
- House-made dressings, jams, and condiments
- Local honey, small-batch pasta, and Mediterranean staples
Visit Us
Find us on
Montague Street
Address
141 Montague St
Brooklyn, NY 11201-3527
Hours
Monday – Friday: 7:00 AM – 8:00 PM
Saturday: 8:00 AM – 8:00 PM
Sunday: 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Ready to place an order?
Call us or stop by — we'll have everything ready when you arrive.
Call (347) 844-9093